Nation Publishing Company Limited have been acquitted of any wrongdoing in the publication of a photograph which appeared on the back page of its newspaper almost two years ago.

But before telling the company’s Publisher Vivian-Anne Gittens, Editor-in-Chief Roy Morris and News Editor Sanka Price that they were free to go, Magistrate Alliston Seale warned them and all other media that there was a need for responsible journalism.

From left Editor-In-Chief Roy Morris, editor Sanka Price, attorney-at-law Ezra Alleyne and Publisher Vivian-Anne Gittens at a previous court appearance.
From left Editor-In-Chief Roy Morris, editor Sanka Price, attorney-at-law Ezra Alleyne and Publisher Vivian-Anne Gittens at a previous court appearance.

The trio were found not guilty of publishing an indecent picture of two minors in the SATURDAY SUN on October 26, 2013.

Seale accepted the no-case submission made by the company’s lawyers Alair Shepherd, QC, and Ezra Alleyne last week in the District ‘D’ Magistrates Court after listening to the arguments of Prosecutor Inspector Eustace Ifill today while sitting in the District ‘A’ Magistrates Court.

Just before he dismissed them, Seale reminded them that it was their social responsibility to be cognizant of what they published.

“I know that sometimes newspapers want to get the jump on their competition . . . but in cases like this I think it would have been better to engage the police rather than go public,” he advised.

“Because sometimes when you try to get the jump in news, you end up with a half baked story where the middle is not cooked.

“I hope that you have learned from your experiences. I accept the no-case submission and the case is dismissed,” Seale stated.

However, he admitted that while the newspaper had received a tongue-lashing for publishing the photograph, the public had to accept that the media had an important role to play in society.

“While it is true that you have the responsibility to protect the young people in our society, the public must still be made aware of what is going on and what our children are being exposed to.

“The public must know and we as citizens must know. We want to hide it, but the truth remains that our schoolchildren are having sex at school when they should be learning their schoolwork,” Seale lamented.

“We must know what is going on in our society and that is the role of the media.”

Earlier, the Magistrate had agreed with Shepherd – who was not present for today’s proceedings – and Alleyne, that the police had erred in charging the trio individually as opposed to charging the Nation Publishing Company Limited.

Seale urged the prosecution to present any evidence – to no avail – which suggested that either of the three had shown an indecent photo to anyone.

He noted that had the Nation Publishing Company Limited been charged, then as employees of the company, they may have been a case against them.

“In my opinion, the Nation Publishing Company Limited should have been charged as an entity itself, even if the individuals had connived or neglected in their duty,” he said.

“There is a difference between whether they stand as the Nation Publishing Company Limited or in their personal capacities. But only in circumstances where there is evidence which shows they did anything in their personal capacity can we go forward.

“The Nation Publishing Company Limited is a separate legal personality which can be charged,” he added.

After being guided by the court, Ifill, who had been assisted by Sergeant Janice Ifill, conceded by saying, “it makes no sense going forward if the court sees it that way.”

The trio had faced up to five years in prison if convicted of the offence.

6 Responses to FREE AT LAST

  1. Tony Webster July 3, 2015 at 2:58 am

    May I express my satisfaction at the Court’s decision, as well as the legal basis Magistrate Seale provided,mans furthermore, also for his reasoning of the importance of a free and responsible media in our society.

    In another time, and in another place, another celebrated jurist of global stature also publicly expressed the distilled wisdom which our citizens would do well to keep close to their heart, as it is a foundation-stone of any viable and healthy democracy-
    ” The price of freedom is eternal vigilance”.

    Any democracy, will not live and provide its citizens a life worth living, whenever access to The Truth, The Whole Truth, and Nothing but the Truth, is in any way is denied or abridged, or distorted, or is not freely available to all its citizens.

    The Truth is like breathing in, and breathing out. WHAT A LOVELY BREATH OF FRESH AIR!

  2. Veroniva Boyce
    Veroniva Boyce July 3, 2015 at 4:05 am

    Waste of time!

  3. Tony Waterman July 3, 2015 at 4:33 am

    The day that these The Nation Three were charged, if you can go back in time you would see that i had written this ending, you would also see that i was soundly whipped by other commenters, and asked why i thought that i knew the laws of Barbados better than the Police, but it was quite evident to me then that they were laying the charges against the wrong persons, so thanks to magistrate for not only vindicating the Nation Three, but also me


  4. Patrick Blackman July 3, 2015 at 8:35 am

    The court is not the place to set social or moral policy, it is the place to interpret and apply the law. When court becomes the moral character of a nation we begin on that road to a slippery slope. Indeed a bad decision in my opinion (not that it matters to anyone).

  5. Kevin July 3, 2015 at 6:41 pm

    Oh yes, just what this country needs, more p o r n. Cant wait for the Sat Sun tomorrow. I need my fix.

  6. villager. July 3, 2015 at 8:36 pm

    I do not agree with this decision, this was a despicable piece of journalism,period and the author should have been the only one headed up the road in st.philip where he would have real experiences,has anyone noticed that the email address for the column he writes has suddenly changed days after this incident,yes the courts decision is final and must be respected but trust me we are going back to more crude stories like doctors say too much rough sex,smh.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *