WASHINGTON – Sanctions for deadly bombing
Over a dozen disciplined for hospital attack
WASHINGTON — More than a dozen American military personnel have been disciplined — but face no criminal charges — for mistakes that led to the bombing of a Doctors Without Borders hospital that killed 42 people in Afghanistan last year, American defence officials say.
The punishments, which have not been publicly announced, are largely administrative. But in some cases the actions, such as letters of reprimand, are tough enough to effectively end chances for further promotion. The military has previously said some personnel were suspended from their duties but has given no further details.
The disciplined include both officers and enlisted personnel, but officials said none are generals.
The officials, who were not authorized to discuss the outcomes publicly and so spoke on condition of anonymity, said the disciplinary process was nearly complete. It is derived from a military investigation of the October 3, 2015 attack, the results of which are expected to be made public in a partially redacted form in coming days.
The hospital, run by the medical charity Doctors Without Borders in the northern city of Kunduz, was attacked by a US Air Force special operations AC-130 gunship, one of the most lethal in the American arsenal. Doctors Without Borders called the attack “relentless and brutal” and demanded an international investigation, but none has been undertaken.
Army General John Campbell, who was the top American commander in Afghanistan at the time but has since relinquished command, has called it a “tragic but avoidable accident caused primarily by human error”.
The attack was unleashed as American military advisers were helping Afghan forces retake Kunduz, which had fallen to the Taliban on September 28. It was the first major city to fall since the Taliban were expelled from Kabul in 2001.
Afghan officials claimed the hospital had been overrun by the Taliban, but no evidence of that has surfaced. The hospital was destroyed and Doctors Without Borders, also known by its French acronym, MSF, ceased operations in Kunduz.
President Barack Obama apologized for the attack, which was one of the deadliest assaults on civilians in the 15-year war.
The American command in Kabul said in February that it had expressed condolences and offered payment to more than 140 families and individuals affected by the attack.
In November the American military provided an outline of what happened. It said the crew of the AC-130 gunship, which is armed with side-firing cannons and guns, had been dispatched to hit a Taliban command centre in a different building, 450 yards away from the hospital. However, hampered by problems with their targeting sensors, the crew relied on a physical description that led them to begin firing at the hospital even though they saw no hostile activity there.
Many chances to avert the error were missed, officials said.
At a November news conference, Brigadier General Wilson Shoffner, a spokesman for Campbell, said the actions taken by the American aircrew were “not appropriate” to the threat they faced, suggesting that a number of them could be faulted.
Campbell and Shoffner said that neither the US Special Forces commander who called in the strike at the request of Afghan forces, nor the American aircrew, was aware that a hospital was being hit until it was too late.
The main US military investigation was completed on November 15 but has not yet been publicly released. US Central Command, which is responsible for US military operations in Afghanistan and across the greater Mideast, rejected in December an AP Freedom of Information Act request for the report, which it said was approximately 5,000 pages long.
A separate American report on the incident, obtained last fall by The Associated Press, said the AC-130 aircraft fired 211 shells at the hospital compound over 29 minutes before commanders realized the mistake and
ordered a halt. Doctors Without Borders officials contacted coalition military personnel during the attack to say the hospital was “being ‘bombed’ from the air”, and the word finally was relayed to the AC-130 crew, the report said.
In an interview with reporters last week, Campbell, who is retiring on May 1, said the fall of Kunduz was a surprise — perhaps even to the Taliban.
“They had no clue they were going to take over Kunduz,” he said. The insurgents had infiltrated a small number of fighters and attacked a prison in the city, he said.
“They got in the prison and the police just kind of left,” and so the Taliban decided to keep pressing with the help of other Afghan police who colluded with the Taliban and were “bought off”, Campbell said.
American special operations forces were then sent to the area in support of Afghan forces.